Perpetual Stew, Or Why It's Safe To Eat A 79-Year-Old Soup (2024)

Perpetual Stew, Or Why It's Safe To Eat A 79-Year-Old Soup (2)PUBLISHED

It's possible to eat a soup that is older than you.

Perpetual Stew, Or Why It's Safe To Eat A 79-Year-Old Soup (3)

James Felton

Perpetual Stew, Or Why It's Safe To Eat A 79-Year-Old Soup (4)

James Felton

Senior Staff Writer

  • email

James is a published author with four pop-history and science books to his name. He specializes in history, strange science, and anything out of the ordinary.

Senior Staff Writer

  • email

EditedbyLaura Simmons

Perpetual Stew, Or Why It's Safe To Eat A 79-Year-Old Soup (5)

Laura Simmons

Editor and Staff Writer

  • email

Laura is an editor and staff writer at IFLScience. She obtained her Master's in Experimental Neuroscience from Imperial College London.

Perpetual Stew, Or Why It's Safe To Eat A 79-Year-Old Soup (6)6Comments

Perpetual Stew, Or Why It's Safe To Eat A 79-Year-Old Soup (7)

In Krung Thep Maha Nakhon (Bangkok), there is an award-winning restaurant called Wattana Panich, where you can order and then eat a beef and goat soup that is 49 years old.

Advertisem*nt

The soup, which is described as "delicious and aromatic" as well as having a "real depth of flavor that's hard to explain", has been brewed by three generations of chefs working at the restaurant. Every night, whatever is in the pot gets stored, and brought out again the following day. More ingredients are added, and the whole process starts again, day in, day out, for decades.

Advertisem*nt

In Japan, the restaurant Otaf*cku in the Asakusa district of Tokyo serves a stew called oden, which has been replenished constantly since 1945. The only reason it doesn't date back until 1916, when the restaurant opened, is said to be because that soup was lost in a World War II air raid. Another soup supposedly lasted from the 15th century until it met its match in World War II too.

As repeat customers, a lack of dead ones, and a range of good Tripadvisor reviews implies, the soups are safe to eat, though we wouldn't recommend making your own at home.

First off, it's not like you're eating chunks of goat from decades ago, some poor kid that met its end in the heady days of disco. Though it may retain traces of the original components, we are definitely in Soup of Theseus territory.


The soups are heated and kept on a rolling simmer regularly, hot enough to kill any bacteria introduced during that day's top-up. As long as no ingredients detrimental to human health are added, and the soup is constantly boiled to temperatures that will kill off harmful bacteria, the soup can be added to and eaten for a long, long time. Maybe one day you'll get a chance to eat a soup that's older than you.

ARTICLE POSTED IN

  • Perpetual Stew, Or Why It's Safe To Eat A 79-Year-Old Soup (9)
  • bacteria,

  • food,

  • soup,

  • food safety,

  • stew,

  • weird and wonderful

Email AppEnvelope

FOLLOW ONNEWSPerpetual Stew, Or Why It's Safe To Eat A 79-Year-Old Soup (10)

Perpetual Stew, Or Why It's Safe To Eat A 79-Year-Old Soup (2024)

FAQs

Perpetual Stew, Or Why It's Safe To Eat A 79-Year-Old Soup? ›

As long as no ingredients detrimental to human health are added, and the soup is constantly boiled to temperatures that will kill off harmful bacteria, the soup can be added to and eaten for a long, long time.

Is perpetual soup safe to eat? ›

And yes, because it's always kept at boiling temperature (there was a close call on June 14 when Shayne briefly blew a fuse making toast), and the ingredients are cycled out at a fast pace, it should be safe to eat. Perpetual stews have been around for a while and “have simmered for years on end!” she notes.

Why don't perpetual stews go bad? ›

"Bacteria known to cause food-borne illness flourishes at temperatures between 40 degrees F (5 degrees C) and 140 degrees F (60 degrees C), but can't survive the heat of a constant simmer." Rauwerda says her stew stays at 200 degrees F (93 degrees C).

Is 50 year old soup safe? ›

the soup, it's completely safe to eat. And over the 45 years, the broth has gotten better and better. I guess. I'll let you know how my stomach's doing in a few days.

What is a perpetual soup? ›

A perpetual stew, also known as forever soup, hunter's pot, or hunter's stew, is a pot into which foodstuffs are placed and cooked, continuously. The pot is never or rarely emptied all the way, and ingredients and liquid are replenished as necessary.

How long is soup safe to eat? ›

Many soups, with the possible exception of seafood soups, may taste better the next day! For best safety and quality, plan to eat refrigerated soup within 3 to 4 days or freeze it. And avoid letting soup set at room temperature for more than TWO hours. Don't put a large pot of hot soup directly into your refrigerator.

What are the benefits of perpetual stew? ›

Perpetual stew stays on simmer for days, months, and even years at a time. As the days progress, you add more ingredients and continue to build on the flavor of the original recipe. The stew's long lifespan encourages fermentation, which accounts for its notable spicy-sour flavor.

What is the longest lasting perpetual stew? ›

In Japan, the restaurant Otaf*cku in the Asakusa district of Tokyo serves a stew called oden, which has been replenished constantly since 1945. The only reason it doesn't date back until 1916, when the restaurant opened, is said to be because that soup was lost in a World War II air raid.

Can you boil bacteria out of soup? ›

To be completely safe, you'll have to boil the soup vigorously for 10 minutes. Doing this will not only kill off any active bacteria, it will also inactivate -- but not destroy -- botulinum spores.

How old is the oldest soup in the world? ›

Wattana Panich - one of the world's oldest soups. (50-year-old beef and goat soup) Definitely a must try resto in Bangkok!

Why does old soup taste better? ›

If left overnight (and saved in a safe, refrigerated place) leftover soup tastes richer the next day because all the flavors have had longer to blend. The same applies to stews.

Why put a stone in soup? ›

One story about the origin of the term stone soup is that during the US's Great Depression, families unable to put food on the table every day simply placed a porous rock in the stock pot on days when there was food - and subsequently flavour - to absorb.

What is the danger zone for perpetual stew? ›

Kept in a cauldron just above the 'danger zone' of 60 degrees celsius, the stock would be made of ale, bread, beans, salted pork, cabbage and whatever else might be at hand, constantly evolving depending on what had been thrown into the pot each day. It would then be served up as a cheap meal for weary travellers.

Does perpetual stew go bad? ›

If you're properly straining your perpetual stew after each "use" or new batch of ingredients and keeping it constantly simmering at around 200 degrees Fahrenheit, you can keep the simmer going as long as you'd like.

What soup has been simmering for 45 years? ›

"Neua Tune": The soup that has been simmering in Bangkok for almost 50 years. The hearty beef broth has been kept simmering by three generations of one family for nearly half a century. The "Wattana Panich" has even received a visit from the Michelin Guide.

Is it safe to eat soup straight from the can? ›

So why, then, is it suggested that we heat canned soups before consumption? To enhance their flavors and, of course, help warm us up from the inside out. All that being said, you can have your pick of any soup to snack on straight from the can, and really any other canned good in your pantry.

Is it safe to eat leftover soup? ›

A general rule of thumb is that soup can be stored in the refrigerator for about three days, but you should always taste your dish before deciding to reheat.

Is soup left out all night safe to eat? ›

On most occasions, you shouldn't leave soup out overnight. This is because when the stock in the soup cools below 130°F, dangerous bacteria can multiply. If you do decide that you want to leave soup out overnight, it's recommended that you boil the soup for 10 minutes to kill any active bacteria.

Are all canned soups unhealthy? ›

While canned soups can be a convenient meal option, it's important to be mindful of their nutritional aspects. Making healthier choices by selecting low-sodium, low-fat, and organic options, adding fresh or frozen vegetables, and opting for BPA-free cans can enhance the nutritional quality of canned soups.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Fredrick Kertzmann

Last Updated:

Views: 6225

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Fredrick Kertzmann

Birthday: 2000-04-29

Address: Apt. 203 613 Huels Gateway, Ralphtown, LA 40204

Phone: +2135150832870

Job: Regional Design Producer

Hobby: Nordic skating, Lacemaking, Mountain biking, Rowing, Gardening, Water sports, role-playing games

Introduction: My name is Fredrick Kertzmann, I am a gleaming, encouraging, inexpensive, thankful, tender, quaint, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.